State versus society? Local government and the reconstruction of the Russian state

by

“This paper sets out to demonstrate that the evolution of Russian local government reflects the continuing debate between two traditions or theories of what local government should be: a centralising tradition which does not recognise the claims of either local autonomy or of political pluralism, and a romantic localism based on the society theory of local self-government, which imbues local self-government with an unrealistic mission and thereby (it may be argued) hinders the development of effective local institutions, and thus indirectly supports the consolidation of the state centralism it is opposed to.

These two approaches to local government come into collision over the status of districts, which are not entirely state or local government institutions. Whereas the 1995 Law on Local Self-Government attempted to keep districts separate from local self-government, this did not prove practicable, and the Law of 2003, by reintroducing districts, may be seen as attempting to bridge the two opposing conception of the status of local government.”

Published in Local Government Studies | A. Campbell | 2006, https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/State-versus-society-Local-government-and-the-of-Campbell/14f4c713dc3a2a4c951c78ffd89ea7935b6d260b, https://consensus.app/details/whereas-1995-selfgovernment-attempted-districts-campbell/30d59bfa26f955d392c0e03f40c68d45/


Related posts:

  1. Local Self-Government Theory and Its Evolution in Modern China “In traditional Chinese society, there have existed certain forms of local self-government theory, which constitute the pre-knowledge and foundation of local self-government theory and its evolution in modern China. Since the late Qing Dynasty, the western theory has been far...
  2. State-Local Relations “The states created their own governing structures. As in other states, Michigan’s constitution and laws formed the local levels of government (nothing in the U.S. Constitution prescribes such entities as K–12 school districts, counties, townships, cities, villages, and authorities), and...
  3. Local Government Autonomy and State Reliance on Special District Governments: A Reassessment “This study challenges the findings of previous studies showing that limitations on local autonomy strongly encourage a splintering of local government authority due to the creation of numerous special districts.” The notion that local government autonomy has important implications for...
  4. Local Level Decentralization in Ethiopia: Case Study of Tigray Regional State “Based on the literature on decentralization, this article investigates the institutional arrangement and autonomy of local governments in Tigray Regional state. It is based on two rounds of field work covering nine districts. At a formal level, local governments are...
  5. Local government in practice: evidence from two villages in northern Albania. “The article concludes that local government has been undervalued and argues for greater attention to be focused on the nexus composed of citizens and the institutions of government which are closest to them.” This article examines how local government operated...
  6. Leadership in local government reform : strategic direction versus administrative compliance “This paper reports on a study into the managerial and organizational responses to the reform of Victorian local government, highlighting the fact that each local authority is unique and that broad policy instruments designed to reform and improve local government...
  7. Bourgeois Theories of Local Government “This paper offers an historical analysis of the principles of local government organization that have been accepted in Britain and the United States. The central thesis is that these principles express an ‘economist’ conception of politics and the state. Local...
  8. Local Government Complexity: Consequences for County Property-Tax and Debt Policies “Consequently, reforms aimed at making the county the “local government of the future” would require perhaps insurmountable changes in state and local structures.” This article examines the consequences of local government complexity on county revenue decisions in fourteen Texas counties...
  9. State Centralization and the Decline of Local Government in Malawi “This article posits that, for various reasons, the centralization of the state and local government administrations has been a dominant characteristic of the Malawi political system. This centralization may be explained by historically specific factors. It has its roots in...
  10. The Rise of Specialized Governance in American Federalism: Testing Links Between Local Government Autonomy and Formation of Special District Governments “Focusing on three dimensions of government autonomy—local government capacity, local government discretion, and local government importance—I find that the growth of certain types of special districts is in part a response to state laws constraining government autonomy of general-purpose governments....