Local Government Autonomy and State Reliance on Special District Governments: A Reassessment

by

“This study challenges the findings of previous studies showing that limitations on local autonomy strongly encourage a splintering of local government authority due to the creation of numerous special districts.”

The notion that local government autonomy has important implications for a state’s local government structure is fast approaching conventional wisdom. Negative binomial regression is used to analyze the link between the administrative, fiscal, functional, and structural autonomy permitted to municipal and county governments and the number of special districts in each state over the 1992-2002 period. This pooled analysis reveals that this relationship to be far more limited than previously thought.

Tax and expenditure limitations (TELs) were the only restrictions that were consistently related to a greater reliance on special district governments, and only when both municipal and county governments were both strongly restricted. For the most part, state reliance on special district governments was unaffected by the extent of restrictions placed on local general-purpose governments with regard to debt and permitted functions.

Published in Political Research Quarterly (formerly WPQ) | Jered B. Carr | 2006, https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Local-Government-Autonomy-and-State-Reliance-on-A-Carr/3d387891ee9ddd6aba35b062541b57ea1f843521, https://consensus.app/details/this-study-challenges-findings-studies-showing-carr/52562fb46da75f1cb3bf2bd8030d1540/

Related posts:

  1. The Rise of Specialized Governance in American Federalism: Testing Links Between Local Government Autonomy and Formation of Special District Governments “Focusing on three dimensions of government autonomy—local government capacity, local government discretion, and local government importance—I find that the growth of certain types of special districts is in part a response to state laws constraining government autonomy of general-purpose governments....
  2. The politics of local government autonomy in Nigeria reloaded “The study concludes that local government is a unique political structure and the degree of autonomy it enjoys from federal or regional or state government is congruent with the politics of the state. Consequently, there is no grand theory of...
  3. State versus society? Local government and the reconstruction of the Russian state “This paper sets out to demonstrate that the evolution of Russian local government reflects the continuing debate between two traditions or theories of what local government should be: a centralising tradition which does not recognise the claims of either local...
  4. Local Level Decentralization in Ethiopia: Case Study of Tigray Regional State “Based on the literature on decentralization, this article investigates the institutional arrangement and autonomy of local governments in Tigray Regional state. It is based on two rounds of field work covering nine districts. At a formal level, local governments are...
  5. Local Government Autonomy in Nigeria: A Historical Perspective “This paper examines the contradictions in local government system and suggests that the sustainability of local government autonomy should anchor on improved revenue base adherence to constitutional provisions, political stability accountability and transparency in governance.” Local governments are not sovereign...
  6. A Reassessment of City/County Consolidation: Economic Development Impacts “Over the past two decades, a large body of literature has examined the fiscal consequences of city/ county consolidation. Much of this research suggests that consolidation results in expansions in local budgets and in the scope and quality of municipal...
  7. Local Government in Tasmania: Reform and Restructuring “…success of amalgamation and reform in local government has been strongly influenced by the degree of local government involvement and support in the reform process, lessons that have wider application.” Tasmania has a long history of failed attempts at restructuring...
  8. Local Government Complexity: Consequences for County Property-Tax and Debt Policies “Consequently, reforms aimed at making the county the “local government of the future” would require perhaps insurmountable changes in state and local structures.” This article examines the consequences of local government complexity on county revenue decisions in fourteen Texas counties...
  9. The Link between Financial Autonomy and Local Development. The Case of Romania “…greater financial autonomy to local government means greater ability of local public authorities to serve the needs of local communities, leading, consequently, to local development.” In recent years, in the European Union, community in which Romania is part, there is...
  10. The Impact of Local Government Organization on Development and Disparities — A Comparative Perspective “Results of the comparative study presented in this paper suggests that local government organization influences land-use planning, and local development strategies and disparities. Local government reforms can, therefore, serve to modify spatial patterns of development and disparities.” Based on a...