Off-budget activities of local government: Comment

by

“The conclusion of this analysis is that tax limitations have brought about an unforeseen improvement in the structure of local government. While the actual implementation in particular cases may not always lead to desirable results, there is hope for improvement. The important consideration is not whether spending is at some particular optimal level, but whether the fiscal constitution has changed so as to generate more rational outcomes. As Professor Buchanan has emphasized, economists should be ‘process-oriented’ rather than ‘outcome-oriented.’ This paper has presented analysis to indicate that the fiscal processes of local government may well have been improved in an unexpected manner.”

Bennett and Dilorenzo have provided evidence that limitations on taxes and spending induce a proliferation of special purpose local government. They conclude that the effects on spending were less than originally supposed. Whatever the effects on total spending, a very important effect on the limitations is an induced change in the fiscal constitution of local government. Using a public choice approach, this institutional change was found to have certain desirable features.

Decreased fiscal illusion and increased accountability is obtained by separating the functions of government and their sources of revenue. This is done by placing general purpose government expenditures ‘off-budget’ and on to a separate special purpose government budget. In effect, the proliferation of governmental units allows for the earmarking of revenues. This allows for more rational decisions in a democratic setting and also limits the exploitation of taxpayers in a nondemocratic setting. The proliferation of governments also allows for more competition among governments and lower public service costs. In addition, alternatives in public services levels may increase consumption efficiency.

Published in Public Choice | R. Blewett | 1984, https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Off-budget-activities-of-local-government%3A-Comment-Blewett/8f493ce25fe1110ed2238227548cc99da1929c18, https://consensus.app/details/conclusion-analysis-limitations-brought-improvement-blewett/2ea3eeed2bdb5a278cf2c48eea1432bb/


Related posts:

  1. The Rise of Specialized Governance in American Federalism: Testing Links Between Local Government Autonomy and Formation of Special District Governments “Focusing on three dimensions of government autonomy—local government capacity, local government discretion, and local government importance—I find that the growth of certain types of special districts is in part a response to state laws constraining government autonomy of general-purpose governments....
  2. Local Government Autonomy and State Reliance on Special District Governments: A Reassessment “This study challenges the findings of previous studies showing that limitations on local autonomy strongly encourage a splintering of local government authority due to the creation of numerous special districts.” The notion that local government autonomy has important implications for...
  3. Do fiscal decentralization and government fragmentation affect corruption in different ways? Evidence from a panel data analysis “Are countries characterized by more decentralized fiscal and spending powers less corrupt? Or is a higher degree of government fragmentation a more effective way to deter corruption? Is there any evidence that these alternative ways to enhance government accountability reinforce...
  4. The Effects of Local Government Amalgamation on Public Spending, Taxation, and Service Levels: Evidence from 15 Years of Municipal Consolidation “We study how municipal amalgamation affects local government spending, taxation, and service provision in the Netherlands. Employing different models, different control groups, and a number of robustness tests, we find no significant effect on aggregate spending or taxation, although spending...
  5. The effects of local government amalgamation on public spending and service levels “We use difference-in-difference estimation to study how municipal amalgamation affects local government spending and public service levels in the Netherlands. Employing different models, different control groups and a number of robustness tests, we find no significant effect on aggregate spending....
  6. Decentralization and the duration of fiscal consolidation: shifting the burden across layers of government “The consolidation of the general government budget appears to be of longer duration when expenditure decisions are more decentralized. We also find that transfers from higher levels of government are cut during consolidation episodes, suggesting that central governments shift the...
  7. Local policies and local government legitimacy. The Swedish case “Local legitimacy is construed as citizens’ assessments of whether the local political system functions in an acceptable way. Distinctions are made between input legitimacy, output legitimacy related to welfare services and output legitimacy that concerns basic collective services. Controlling for...
  8. Is Small Beautiful? The Quasi-experimental Analysis of the Impact of Territorial Fragmentation on Costs in Polish Local Governments “Results of the study are to a large extent a mirror of earlier analysis of territorial amalgamation consequences, which confirms the importance of scale for administrative costs, but not necessarily for costs of other local services.” Debates on the impact...
  9. Bourgeois Theories of Local Government “This paper offers an historical analysis of the principles of local government organization that have been accepted in Britain and the United States. The central thesis is that these principles express an ‘economist’ conception of politics and the state. Local...
  10. Local Government and Local Development: Bridging the Gap through Critical Discourse: Evidence from the Commonwealth Caribbean “A critical analysis of local government reform policies in Trinidad and Tobago and Jamaica revealed substantive convergence around local development as an outcome of reform but also important divergence in the approach to achieving this goal which suggests the absence...