Is Small Beautiful? The Quasi-experimental Analysis of the Impact of Territorial Fragmentation on Costs in Polish Local Governments

by

“Results of the study are to a large extent a mirror of earlier analysis of territorial amalgamation consequences, which confirms the importance of scale for administrative costs, but not necessarily for costs of other local services.”

Debates on the impact of size of subnational jurisdiction on the costs of public-service delivery have a very long tradition, but results are still far from conclusive. This article applies a quasi-experimental scheme of the synthetic control method for Polish municipal fragmentation to analyze the impact of territorial reform on administrative spending as well as on the operating surplus of the budget.

Earlier studies using similar methods focused on amalgamation reforms, so the study of territorial fragmentation is an important new contribution to knowledge on scale effects. The analysis clearly confirms the existence of economy of scale in administrative services. The result for the operating surplus is less clear and more ambiguous. 

Published in Urban Affairs Review | P. Swianiewicz | 2019, https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Is-Small-Beautiful-The-Quasi-experimental-Analysis-Swianiewicz-%C5%81ukomska/a058651fb03e2d2192f74eb3d9047e89f890756f, https://consensus.app/details/results-study-extent-mirror-earlier-analysis-swianiewicz/4ac994f766ae5aa58ad10e72dcc2e104/

Related posts:

  1. The Economic and Political Impacts of Top-Down Territorial Reforms: The Case of Sub-City Governments “Our findings indicate that higher levels of sub-city fragmentation lead to increased municipal government spending and transfers to sub-city governments, thus suggesting that the amalgamation of sub-city governments required by the Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) signed in 2011 by the...
  2. What are the Local Political Costs of Centrally Determined Reforms of Local Government? “Taking advantage of a quasi-experimental setting and drawing upon analysis of electoral results and a survey of voters, this article explores the political costs of reform through the example of the 2009 local elections in Denmark. The article finds that...
  3. The evidence on the existence of economies of scale in local government units “This does not imply that more extensive amalgamation is not warranted, but it demands that other arguments justifying municipal amalgamation should be presented.” The purpose of this paper is to empirically verify if the possible existence of scale economies actually...
  4. Bigger but not always better: Size and democracy in Israeli amalgamated local governments “This study reveals that amalgamation reduces local democracy in terms of voter turnout and representation. The likelihood of having a greater level of local democracy increases in smaller local governments, in terms of population. “ “The new efficiency and democracy...
  5. The Expenditure Impacts of Unification in a Small Georgia County: A Contingency Perspective of City-County Consolidation ” This study offers evidence of greater efficiency and reduced costs in general government or administrative services when the consolidation occurs in a relatively small county. Based on an analysis of real operating expenditures in the United Government of Athens-Clarke...
  6. Impact of municipal mergers on local population growth: an assessment of the merger of Japanese municipalities “By employing propensity score-matching, it is found that, in Japan, municipal mergers negatively affect population growth for municipalities if they are not the largest municipalities among their merging partners. This finding suggests that not all pre-merger areas benefit from municipal...
  7. Municipal amalgamation: The impact on economic development in Chatham-Kent “A series of municipal amalgamations that took place in the 1990s in Ontario, which were justified as a means to “reduce the size of government and to promote economic development” (Sancton, 2000). However, it is unclear if the latter goal...
  8. Cost Inefficiency of Municipalities after Amalgamation “The estimation results showed that municipality amalgamation produces integration costs (slack) in an administrative organization” This paper focuses on the increase in slack costs due to municipality amalgamation, which is pushed forward in several countries to achieve economies of scale....
  9. Does Municipal Amalgamation Strengthen the Financial Viability of Local Government? A Canadian Example “Municipal amalgamation is often seen as one way to ensure that municipalities are large enough to be financially and technically capable of providing the extensive array of services with which they are charged. The idea is presumably that municipalities will...
  10. Impact of municipal amalgamation on stakeholder collaboration: the case of Auckland, New Zealand “Local councils governing Auckland, New Zealand, underwent restructuring in 2010, amalgamating eight local authorities and establishing the Auckland Council as a unitary authority. Key objectives for Auckland’s amalgamation included achieving reform and a single direction in governance, facilitating democratic representation...