Where are the cost savings in city–county consolidation?

by

“Although the results of the four cases are mixed, we find that in some cases there are cost savings associated with city–county consolidation, more frequently in specific functional categories than in overall spending.

We also find that it is necessary to examine spending patterns over several years after consolidation. In some cases, short‐term savings dissipate over time. In other cases, initially modest savings grow over time due to a reduction in spending growth.”

Although proposals for city–county consolidation are often justified on the basis of reducing government expenditures or improving efficiency, few studies find that expenditures are actually reduced after consolidation. This study examines long‐term spending trends in four consolidated city–county jurisdictions for periods of eight to ten years pre‐ and post‐consolidation.

Published in Journal of Urban Affairs | Charles D. Taylor | 2017 https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Where-are-the-cost-savings-in-city%E2%80%93county-Taylor-Faulk/42a6c1331b6acbb733bcde475388d26dd0b49b0e

Related posts:

  1. Cost Savings From Consolidating North Dakota’s Counties “The results indicate that the 15-county proposal would have achieved cost savings of 4.9 percent for the four service categories. Costs of road and highway, general government, and health and welfare services could be reduced 3, 10, and 15 percent,...
  2. The Expenditure Impacts of Unification in a Small Georgia County: A Contingency Perspective of City-County Consolidation ” This study offers evidence of greater efficiency and reduced costs in general government or administrative services when the consolidation occurs in a relatively small county. Based on an analysis of real operating expenditures in the United Government of Athens-Clarke...
  3. The Varieties of Consolidation Experience: A Synthesis and Extension of Local Government Consolidation Models “This article revises and extends Leland and Thurmaier’s (2004a, 2004b) City—County Consolidation (C3) model by synthesizing it with Johnson’s (2004) Theory of Local Constitutional Change (LCC) and Hughes and Lee’s (2002) Evolutionary Consolidation Model (ECM). The result, we find, is...
  4. Impact Analyses of City-County Consolidation on Urban Growth in South Korea “The results show that city-county consolidation has a significantly positive impact on growth of population and urbanized areas. Also, consolidated cities, compared to those failing to be consolidated, show a stronger tendency to balanced growth between former central cities and...
  5. Examining the relationship between municipal consolidation and cost reduction: an instrumental variable approach “Because consolidation seems to increase per capita expenditure in the absence of the effect of this long-term declining trend, incorporating this trend into estimation is crucial in cost-efficiency analysis of consolidation. It is also shown that conventional panel data regressions...
  6. The economic impact of city–county consolidations: a synthetic control approach “The results from the three cases explored indicate that consolidation does not guarantee development and actually can have negative effects. Additionally, consolidation can deepen the urban-rural divide by accelerating the decline of rural populations relative to those of urban areas....
  7. The Future of Police Consolidation “As community reluctance to total city-county consolidation is likely to continue, less drastic methods of centralizing and coordinating key services among law enforcement agencies are recommended.” Consolidation of police services is a continuing concern in American law enforcement. Spearheaded by...
  8. A Reassessment of City/County Consolidation: Economic Development Impacts “Over the past two decades, a large body of literature has examined the fiscal consequences of city/ county consolidation. Much of this research suggests that consolidation results in expansions in local budgets and in the scope and quality of municipal...
  9. The Economic and Political Impacts of Top-Down Territorial Reforms: The Case of Sub-City Governments “Our findings indicate that higher levels of sub-city fragmentation lead to increased municipal government spending and transfers to sub-city governments, thus suggesting that the amalgamation of sub-city governments required by the Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) signed in 2011 by the...
  10. Voting in City-County Consolidation Referenda Voter acceptances of city-county consolidations have been few. Since the end of World War II, consolidation has been attempted twenty-four times and has succeeded only in Baton Rouge, Nashville, Jacksonville, Columbus and in three Virginia areas. The difficulty of obtaining...