The Varieties of Consolidation Experience: A Synthesis and Extension of Local Government Consolidation Models

by

“This article revises and extends Leland and Thurmaier’s (2004a, 2004b) City—County Consolidation (C3) model by synthesizing it with Johnson’s (2004) Theory of Local Constitutional Change (LCC) and Hughes and Lee’s (2002) Evolutionary Consolidation Model (ECM). The result, we find, is a more general model of local government consolidation. Our model is applicable to a wider variety of consolidation types and incorporates a full consideration of varied charter development processes. Ultimately, this allows for acknowledgment of the possibility that consolidation attempts may be halted prior to a referendum campaign and that those attempts may reflect either conflicts of interest or consensual efforts at problem-solving.

We focus specifically on Indiana after enactment of the 2006 Government Modernization Act. After enactment of the act, Indiana experienced seven consolidation efforts from 2008 to 2012. Examination of these efforts provides a robust comparative case study of consolidation efforts occurring during a narrow timeframe and under a common institutional context. The study not only illustrates the suitability of our revised and extended model, but it also confirms a number of Leland and Thurmaier’s (2005) findings from their reassessment of the C3 model.”

Charles D. Taylor | 2020, https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/The-Varieties-of-Consolidation-Experience%3A-A-and-of-Taylor-Faulk/8c00955179d173601df15f4cbd6d279c76470383, https://consensus.app/details/result-find-model-government-consolidation-taylor/dc63a9e378955bfbb54c95f4db44fd02/



Related posts:

  1. When Efficiency Is Unbelievable: Normative Lessons from 30 Years of City–County Consolidations “…the essential element of a successful consolidation is a group of civic elites who define the economic development vision for the community, determine that the existing political structure is incapable of supporting and implementing that vision, and convince the voters...
  2. Frame the Consolidation Debate with a Sound Argument: A Reply to a Response “The most persuasive argument in favor of city–county consolidation has been—and remains—economic development through the formation of a strong and attractive regional community identity. Empirical evidence consistently demonstrates that appeals to voters based on reducing inner-city/suburban socioeconomic inequity and enhancing...
  3. Municipal consolidation and local government behavior: evidence from Japanese voting data on merger referenda “Municipalities that could enjoy large economies of scale from consolidation prefer consolidation, while large and small municipalities are likely to merge. Moreover, municipalities receiving large unconditional grants from the central government are unlikely to merge.” The empirical literature investigating the...
  4. Internalization of externalities and local government consolidation: empirical evidence from Japan “It is found that residents of the municipalities that can internalize a large amount of public goods spillovers through municipal consolidation tend to favor consolidation. This result supports the theoretical inference that spillovers in local public goods affect utility gains...
  5. Where are the cost savings in city–county consolidation? “Although the results of the four cases are mixed, we find that in some cases there are cost savings associated with city–county consolidation, more frequently in specific functional categories than in overall spending. We also find that it is necessary...
  6. The Impact of Local Government Organization on Development and Disparities — A Comparative Perspective “Results of the comparative study presented in this paper suggests that local government organization influences land-use planning, and local development strategies and disparities. Local government reforms can, therefore, serve to modify spatial patterns of development and disparities.” Based on a...
  7. The Consolidation of Local Government Services: The Incidence and Practice of Service Delivery Consolidation in North Carolina “This research does suggest strong support from county managers concerning the potential for service consolidation to enhance service delivery, efficiency and accountability. This research confirms that practitioners view the potential of service consolidation as an enhancement to local government organizations....
  8. A Reassessment of City/County Consolidation: Economic Development Impacts “Over the past two decades, a large body of literature has examined the fiscal consequences of city/ county consolidation. Much of this research suggests that consolidation results in expansions in local budgets and in the scope and quality of municipal...
  9. Examining the relationship between municipal consolidation and cost reduction: an instrumental variable approach “Because consolidation seems to increase per capita expenditure in the absence of the effect of this long-term declining trend, incorporating this trend into estimation is crucial in cost-efficiency analysis of consolidation. It is also shown that conventional panel data regressions...
  10. A Fresh Look at Municipal Consolidation in Australia “Data revealed little evidence of consistent economies of scale from consolidation, however both case studies and interviews indicated that consolidation generated economies of scope and what may be termed ‘strategic capacity’. While it was not possible to disaggregate the data...