Why voluntary municipal merger projects fail: evidence from popular votes in Switzerland

by

“What determines the failure of local government amalgamation referenda? Existing research suggests that functional pressures act as a push factor towards local territorial reform, whereas considerations of political self-determination exert a pull effect. However, we know little about the respective importance of these countervailing forces.

In this paper, I analyze popular vote decisions on mergers of 541 municipalities involved in 166 different merger projects in three Swiss cantons since the new millennium. The results show that both functional pressures and concerns for self-determination are linked to popular vote outcomes: small municipalities are less likely to reject a merger.

Concerns for self-determination matter, but only when the pressures of smallness are not overwhelming: a higher vote share of right-wing parties and a preponderance of other municipalities in the merger coalition increase the probability that voters reject a merger project. This has implications for policy-makers’ strategies when drafting and promoting voluntary local amalgamation reforms.”

Published in Local Government Studies | M. Strebel | 2019, https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Why-voluntary-municipal-merger-projects-fail%3A-from-Strebel/0c58dbff359ded23f7f5bd7563fce1ff1d1f94a8, https://consensus.app/details/this-implications-policymakers-strategies-drafting-strebel/1fa935d0d86558feadfe8d2fe03ee444/

Related posts:

  1. Incented Voluntary Municipal Mergers as a Two-Stage Process: Evidence from the Swiss Canton of Fribourg “Voluntary mergers of local jurisdictions in Europe gained in importance in the last two decades. A debated but rarely analyzed issue in this field is the impact of different local characteristics on the probability to merge. The article contributes to...
  2. Impact of municipal mergers on local population growth: an assessment of the merger of Japanese municipalities “By employing propensity score-matching, it is found that, in Japan, municipal mergers negatively affect population growth for municipalities if they are not the largest municipalities among their merging partners. This finding suggests that not all pre-merger areas benefit from municipal...
  3. Do Municipal Mergers Reduce Costs? Evidence from a German Federal State “We find significant reductions in (administrative) expenditures after compulsory mergers. Voluntary mergers, on the other hand, have no effect on expenditures. We also show that the effects of voluntary and compulsory mergers vary according to further (secondary) characteristics of a...
  4. The Political Economy of Municipal Amalgamation – Evidence of Common Pool Effects and Local Public Debt “This paper investigates the political economy of after merger effects of the large scale municipal amalgamations in the German state of Baden-Wurttemberg in the early 1970s. By exploiting the huge variance in the amalgamation process in terms of number of...
  5. Municipal Merger and Local Democracy: An Assessment of the Merger of Japanese Municipalities “After controlling for potential confounding factors, the analysis shows that municipal merger is negatively correlated to legislative performance.” Municipal mergers have been widely used as a tool for administrative reform. The goal of most municipal mergers is to increase the...
  6. Municipal Amalgamation in Japan: Who Is Happy? “In order to improve efficiency in local government public services, Japan’s central government has implemented a strategy of amalgamation of municipalities and created larger local government units. Since the Meiji Restoration (1868) there have been three big waves of amalgamations...
  7. Merger mania : the assault on local government “Outside the United States, forced municipal mergers were a popular policy in many European countries and Canadian provinces during the 1960s and 1970s. The city of Laval, just north of Montreal, and the “unicity” of Winnipeg owe their origins to...
  8. Municipal consolidation and local government behavior: evidence from Japanese voting data on merger referenda “Municipalities that could enjoy large economies of scale from consolidation prefer consolidation, while large and small municipalities are likely to merge. Moreover, municipalities receiving large unconditional grants from the central government are unlikely to merge.” The empirical literature investigating the...
  9. Municipal Preferences for State-imposed Amalgamations: An Empirical Study Based on the Swedish Municipal Reform of 1952 “This paper concerns municipal preferences for state-imposed municipal amalgamations, focusing on factors that may explain municipal acceptance of, or objection to, a state-imposed amalgamation decision. The empirical analysis is based on the extensive municipal reform that occurred in Sweden in...
  10. The Political Economy of Municipal Amalgamation – Evidence of Common Pool Effects and Local Public Debt “By exploiting the huge variance in the amalgamation process in terms of number of participating municipalities, municipality size or amalgamation strategy we identify considerable common pool effects. Amalgamations can create a common pool, as the former independent municipalities have now...