Running The Big Smoke: A Critical Analysis of the KPMG (2008) Approach to Local Government Reform in the Sydney Metropolitan Area

by

“Following a critique of the current local governance arrangements in the greater Sydney metropolitan area by Blakely and Hu (2007), an alternative approach to the status quo has been advocated in Governance Arrangements for Sydney’s Local Government Authorities (KPMG, 2008). This approach is aimed at rescaling local governance in Sydney to achieve greater global competitiveness, secure better communities of interest, and ensure long-run financial sustainability.

The analysis in this Report has formed the basis for policy proposals calling for inter alia a ‘reconfiguration’ of small local councils in the Sydney metropolitan area into larger units. This paper seeks to provide a critical evaluation of Governance Arrangements for Sydney’s Local Government Authorities. It demonstrates that the empirical analysis conducted in this Report does not support the policy conclusions drawn by its authors for the amalgamation of small councils into larger municipalities. Moreover, the paper argues that the Report should have employed different arguments to those it invoked in support of the establishment of a regional authority for greater Sydney.”

Published in The Australasian Journal of Regional Studies | B. Dollery | 2012, https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/RUNNING-THE-BIG-SMOKE%3A-A-CRITICAL-ANALYSIS-OF-THE-Dollery-Fiorillo/d9f97978efae8d975c3c2dc6ce418b5e1e1e60e3, https://consensus.app/details/demonstrates-analysis-conducted-report-support-policy-dollery/de111f6eb51457779e090a65f2ad9036/

Related posts:

  1. The impact of metropolitan amalgamations in Sydney on municipal financial sustainability “The empirical analysis reported indicates that the proposed amalgamations will not secure enhanced financial sustainability in Greater Sydney local government.” The Australian Independent Local Government Review Panel recently proposed amalgamating the majority of New South Wales (NSW) local councils in...
  2. One Size Does Not Fit All: The Special Case of Remote Small Local Councils in Outback Queensland “Despite the recent limited forced consolidation experienced by some RAPAD councils, we find that the ‘tyranny of distance’ afflicting RAPAD members means that it is not amenable to ‘top-down’ reform measures, like council amalgamation, and policy makers should instead focus...
  3. Improving Efficiency in Australian Local Government: Structural Reform as a Catalyst for Effective Reform “It is argued that ‘top-down’ state government structural reform policy initiatives carrying the threat of amalgamation constitute an efficient mechanism for evoking optimal ‘bottom-up’ structural change models.” Municipal amalgamation has been the main policy instrument of local government structural reform...
  4. Local government amalgamation policy: A highway maintenance evaluation “While new governance practices introduced contemporaneously lifted the level of performance of local authorities in terms of higher technical efficiency, there is no evidence that the amalgamation policy contributed to this improvement.” Abstract: “Evaluating the effects of a change in...
  5. The reform of local government structure in Wales: A critique of the case for unitary authorities “The Welsh Office has proposed that local government in Wales be restructured to produce a system of 20 unitary authorities based on the boundaries of the existing 37 district councils. All eight of the Welsh county councils will be abolished....
  6. Misconceiving Regional/Local Tensions: Two case studies from Tasmania “While tensions between the imperatives of regional, state and national development and local autonomy are common, there is no necessary trade-off between the two since regional development can co-exist with a vibrant system of local government. However, this is often...
  7. Structural Reform in Australian Local Government “Amalgamation has always been the favoured Australian policy instrument for improving the efficiency of Local government. However, this policy consensus has flown against mounting evidence that amalgamation not only often fails to reduce costs, but also generates significant unintended negative...
  8. Optimal approaches to structural reform in regional and rural local governance: The Australian experience “This paper argues that such reliance on the blunt instrument of municipal consolidation has been misplaced, not only because it is based on the mistaken premise that ‘bigger is better’ in local governance, but also because it ignores many other...
  9. The Implications of the Lyons Report into Local Government in England for Structural Reform in Australian Local Government “It is argued that the Lyons Inquiry adds weight to other work that questions the traditional reliance on amalgamation as the chief instrument of Australian local government reform.” The Lyons Inquiry into English local government presented its Final Report in...
  10. More Tinkering with Local Government Finance “Adopting a strategic approach to local government structure, functions and finance, this article demonstrates how the need for intergovernmental transfers can be minimised and financial autonomy restored to local governments. It argues that central government pays unnecessarily large transfers to...