“Expansion has been from the earliest day the policy of our country…evidence from fathers of the republic”

I’m not sure union is in any way imminent — the plethora of American companies with Canadian subsidiaries, most of which are located in central Canada, seems to indicate that there’s many vested interests whose entire existence depends on upholding the status quo.

Union would certainly complicate affairs for the old Province of Canada, eradicating the artificial economic boost provided to Ontario and Quebec through their role as a kind of exclusive gateway to the US economy — in a similar way to Canadian media entities whose role appears to be as an exclusive gateway to US culture. Only they have the authoritative perspective on American issues and politics that “good Canadians” share, which is almost always about framing the overton window around Democratic party talking points while delegitimizing Republicans and Independents.

In some ways it appears the status quo has settled around the feelings of Gouvernour Morris, who said: “I always thought when we should acquire Canada … it would be proper to govern them as provinces, and allow them no voice in our councils”, (the US Senate), which, with the creation of “Canada” in 1867, was all but guaranteed.

It’s undeniable that the founders were keenly aware of the colonies to America’s north, that some considered them proto-States on an indeterminate timeline to union. If one can set aside the idea of statehood and instead examine the powers of self-government afforded to US territories, it’s clear that even they stand far above and beyond the forever status of childhood imposed on the people “of Canada” by the BNA, though perhaps not its provinces.

I’m in complete agreement with Jefferson, that “no constitution was ever before so well calculated as ours for extensive empire and self-government”. Federalism allows for great difference of opinion as it relates to particularists, while at the same time lending great strength in union, an inversion of that imposed by “Canada” and its clumsy carpentry.

I wonder what the reaction from Nova Scotians would have been, had they known that Washington remembered their pleas from years earlier?

“It’s Only A Question Of Time.” Old Fogyism May Hold Her Back For A While, But She Is Bound To Come To Us.

In all the important ways Canada owes its very existence to the United States. Whether through official channels such as becoming a literal territory, an annexation or adjunct, or as a supposedly “sovereign” and “independent” country, we’ve already “come to them”, we are their buffer state in a number of ways, our security and economy will always depend on what is also a cultural behemoth next door.

The relationship more recently seems to have decayed into a kind of lawfare, in terms of Federal legislation in Canada designed to “answer” the laws of several of the States, interleaved into “newsworthy topics” every evening — along with guns and abortion which serve as a constant drumbeat from “Canadian media” to portray what is Canadian by what is not, namely that which is “American”, a portrayal which will surely misunderstand the topic at hand along with federalism and the constitutions of its 50 parts in order to paint a certain picture for political purposes, treating “Canada” as a unitary monolith in opposition.

It seems to me this divergence is on the increase and that it isn’t at all organic, which I can only assume is how “Ottawa” wants it. There is also “the mother country and her dependencies”, let alone other foreign actors colonial and otherwise to account for. An additional, even more depressing possibility which I haven’t fully accounted for, is that it might be how Uncle Sam wants it — that America’s interests are best served from their perspective by the status quo.


“And lastly, another Province (Nova Scotia), which some time ago was very desirous of it, would be added to the Federal Union. It may not be amiss to give Bermuda some consideration, as circumstances in the course of the campaign may lead to the conquest of this island, without incurring much expense, or interfering with other plans. Policy in this case may invite the measure whether it is adopted with a view of retaining or ceding the island by way of composition at a general pacification. Some good and no bad consequences can result from an attempt to take this island by surprise. The island might be carried without much, if any, opposition ; for it is presumed very little would come from the inhabitants, who have often expressed a wish to be united with America and enjoy the benefit of its support.” —George Washington in his Plan of Campaign for the year 1782, in the Revolutionary War, drawn up by him at Newburgh, May 1st, 1782

“Wanting scarcely anything but the free navigation of the Mississippi, which we must have and as certainly shall have as we remain a nation, I have supposed that, with the undeviating exercise of a just, steady and prudent national policy, we shall be the gainers, whether the Powers of the Old World may be in peace or war, but more especially in the latter case.” —George Washington, in a letter to Lafayette, August 11th, 1790.

” I see no objection to our indulging a hope that this country (Canada), of such importance in the present controversy, may yet be added to and complete our Union.” —George Washington, in a letter to General Sullivan, June 16th, 1776.

“The accounts which you had received of the accession of Canada to the Union were premature. It is a measure much to be wished, and I believe would not be displeasing to the body of that people. Your ideas of its importance to our political union coincide exactly with mine. If that country is not with us, it will, from its proximity to the Eastern States, its intercourse and connection with the numerous tribes of Western Indians, its communion with them by water and other local advantages, be at least a troublesome if not a dangerous neighbor to us; and ought, at all events, to be in the same interests and politics of the other States.” —George Washington, in a letter from Valley Forge to Landon Carter, May 30th, 1778.


“Britain possesses Canada. It might be humiliating to her to give it up on the demand of America. Perhaps America will not demand it. But on the mind of the people in general would it not have an excellent effect if Britain should voluntarily offer to give up this province? And I hinted that, if England should make us a voluntary offer of Canada expressly for the purpose of effecting durable peace and sweet reconciliation, it might have a good effect.”

Benjamin Franklin in 1782 in negotiating with Richard Oswald, the British Envoy, the Treaty of Peace at the close of the Revolutionary War. ” If the United States should think fit to attempt the reduction of the British power in the northern parts of America, or the islands of Bermudas, those countries or islands, in case of success, shall be confederated or dependent upon the said United States.” —Benjamin Franklin in Treaty with France in 1778, written by him.


“Standing here and looking far off into the Northwest I see the Russian as he busily occupies himself in establishing seaports’, and towns, and fortifications, on the verge of this continent, as the outposts of St. Petersburg, and I can say, ‘ Go on and build up your outposts all along the coast, even up to the Arctic Ocean—they will yet become the outposts of my own country—monuments of the civilization of the United States in the Northwest.’ So I look off on Prince Rupert’s Land and Canada and see there an ingenious, enterprising and ambitious people occupied with bridging rivers and constructing canals, railroads and telegraphs to organize and preserve British provinces north of the Great Lakes, the St. Lawrence and around the shores of the Hudson Bay, and I am able to say: ‘It is very well; you are building excellent States to be hereafter admitted into the American Union.'”

William H. Seward in a speech at St. Paul September 18, 1850. “A war about these fisheries ( the British fisheries in North America) would be a war which would result either in the independence of the British provinces or in their annexation to the United States. I devoutly pray God that that consummation may come, the sooner the better; but I do not desire it at the cost of war, or injustice. I am content to wait for the ripened fruit which must fall.” —William H. Seward in a speech in the Senate August 14, 1852.


“We should then have only to include the North in our Confederacy, which would be of course in the first war, and we should have such an empire for liberty as she has never surveyed since the creation ; and I am persuaded no constitution was ever before so well calculated as ours for extensive empire and self-government.”

Thomas Jefferson, in a letter from Monticello to James Madison, April 21th, 1809. “Although it is acknowledged that our new fellow citizens (of Louisiana) are as yet incapable of self-government as children, yet some cannot bring themselves to suspend its principles for a single moment.” —Thomas Jefferson, in a letter to De Witt Clinton, Dec. 2d, 1803.

GOUVERNEUR MORRIS said: “I always thought when we should acquire Canada and Louisiana it would be proper to govern them as provinces, and allow them no voice in our councils. In wording the third section of the fourth article of the Constitution I went as far as circumstances would permit, to establish the exclusion.’

Gouverneur Morris of New York, who wrote the third section of the fourth article of the Constitution, in a letter to Henry W. Livingston, December 4, 1803.” The Congress shall have power to make all needful rules and regulations respecting territory or other property belonging to the United States.” Section 3, Article 4, of the Constitution.” I knew then, as well as I do now, that all North America must at length be annexed to us.” —Gouverneur Morris in a letter to Henry W. Livingston, November 25th, 1803.

[Article IV, Section 3: New States may be admitted by the Congress into this Union; but no new State shall be formed or erected within the Jurisdiction of any other State, nor any State be formed by the Junction of two or more States, or parts of States, without the Consent of the Legislatures of the States concerned as well of the Congress.

The Congress shall have Power to dispose of and make all needful Rules and Regulations respecting the Territory or other Property belonging to the United States; and nothing in this Constitution shall be so construed as to Prejudice any Claims of the United States, or of any particular State.]

UNITY OF EMPIRE. ALEXANDER HAMILTON’S IDEAS CONCERNING THE BEST INTERESTS OF THE UNITED ” Besides the eventual security against invasion, we ought certainly to look to the possession of the Floridas and Louisiana, and we ought to squint at South America. —Alexander Hamilton in a letter to James McHenry, June 21th, 1799. ” I have been long in the habit of considering the acquisition of those countries (Louisiana and Florida) as essential to the permanency of the Union.”

Alexander Hamilton, in a letter to H. G. Otis, Jan. 26th, 1799.” The Farmer, I am inclined to hope, builds too much upon the present disunion of Canada, Georgia, the Floridas, the Mississippi and Nova Scotia from other Colonies. I please myself with the flattering prospect that they will, ere long, unite in one indissoluble chain with the rest of the Colonies.” —Alexander Hamilton, in his ” Vindication of the Measures of Congress” in 1774.”

Walker, Albert H. (Albert Henry). “Expansion has been from the earliest day the policy of our country. The evidence from the fathers of the republic” New York, Republican National Committee, [1900?] http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.gdc/scd0001.00139014698